Oink founder Alan Ellis not guilty

Editor's picture

Alan Ellis, the founder of the OiNK BitTorrent tracker, has been found not guilty of fraud.

At the end of the two week trial the jury returned a unanimous verdict (12 to 0). Alan Ellis is not guilty of Conspiracy to Defraud the music industry. He walked out of Teesside Crown Court a free man today, his name cleared. The verdict cannot be appealed and Ellis can finally put the past behind him and move on.

Ellis's defense made a strong attack on the music industry:

For the defense, Alex Stein said that Ellis had never knowingly acted dishonestly and that in 2004 when OiNK was launched, it was a “brave new world” on the Internet. “In many societies he’d be an innovator, a creator, a Richard Branson. His talent would be moulded, not crushed by some sort of media organization,” he said. The media organization being referred to by Stein was the IFPI, who he said had never requested that OiNK be shut down, and had instead “sat and watched.”

Gazette Live reports that Stein went on to launch a scathing attack on the IFPI: “They used this site. Their own members used this site to promote their own music and now they’re crushing him. Maybe he grew too big for them, maybe they’ve taken a different marketing approach. I don’t know. But it was decided that this site should be taken down.”

This case raises some questions:

1. Why was Ellis charged with fraud? Fraud in essence means using deception to get money. It seems obvious to me that running a BitTorrent tracker isn't using deception, unless you go round telling people it is'nt a BitTorrent tracker. Why wasn't he instead charged with contributory copyright infringement?

2. Is he allowed to put Oink back up again? If not, the authorities are negating the verdict of their own courts.

3. Since he has been found not guilty, are the police and/or IFPI going to compensate him for the loss of revenue while OiNK was down? If not, this is a serious miscarriage of justice.



And there was a time I enjoyed Patricia Heaton as an arcetss. This is supposed to be a composed Christian conservative who cares about all life Whether you're pro-choice or pro-life, that just unnecessary and digusting.Fluke didn't talk about her sex life at the hearing, and even if she did, its really none of Heaton's or any other Right Wing panty raider's business. There are plenty of good, moral women who take birth control some women use birth control because they'd rather not pop out kids every time they're intimate with their partner. Some others use birth control so they can actually have children. See, hormonal imbalances can make women infertile. One common treatment for this ailment is the pill.Whatever the reason, unless you're that woman or her partner, its not your business. Just like Jehova Witnesses shouldn't get froggy when other people get blood transfusions, Christian Scientists can't stop other people from taking prescriptions and Jewish people tend not care if people take Flu vaccine or have pig heart valve replacements because its technically not kosher all the Catholic vagina police need back out of other people's private medical lives. http://wkdwfggi.com [url=http://eycgsbvwohv.com]eycgsbvwohv[/url] [link=http://pvmltexg.com]pvmltexg[/link]

I'll second that some<a href="http://ubgcdvqpt.com"> fcsninatiag</a> stories. In David Barlow's account of his introduction to life as an RO, I picked up on the comment that he wished he had been taught to type. I well recall being taught to touch type at Norwood Technical College (NTC); the keys were covered over and we were sent Morse code to transcribe. The idea was that we would directly correlate,for example, the Morse sequence dot dash as little finger of left hand in the middle row without associating it with the letter A. This is a skill that has never left me, and I've been grateful for my typing ability ever since. Especially now that we all use keyboards for everything. So I was surprised to read that typing was not taught at Colwyn Bay. Was NTC unique in this, or was it a later update to the syllabus? (I was there in 1958-ish.)Talking of NTC, I was told that unofficially if one wanted to contact other ex-NTC ROs while at sea one would call for GNTC. Did this ever happen, or was it wishful thinking?PhilG3UGK

Well, well, well. When I find myself wnsiihg that some insured people would get cancer so that they can find out what it's like when the insurance pool covers their treatment I don't nurse that feeling, but I don't fight it like I used to either. Sad thing is, I think a lot of people with the attitudes we see expressed here are absolutely convinced that it's always different for THEM. And Katie, be sure to tell any man who might want to marry you that you think dealing with children is the best form of birth control, and try to tell him what that MEANS. http://blywzhwlz.com [url=http://mlxrusfucs.com]mlxrusfucs[/url] [link=http://wuafpajr.com]wuafpajr[/link]

Add new comment

To prevent spam, we'd like to check that you are not a bot - log in to avoid these!
Enter the characters shown in the image.